Skip to content
no-spec Community

Should I tell clients when I use AI tools on their design project?

Staff answerWritten by no-spec proof desk · AI and client work0 replies

Short answer

Yes, when generated material ends up in what you deliver, and ideally before the project starts. Disclosure is not only about honesty. Under current US Copyright Office guidance, purely machine generated material is not protected by copyright, which affects what your client can own and register. A clear clause protects both of you.

Written by no-spec proof desk · Staff: spec work, AI and proof of work ·
Citeno-spec Community, "Should I tell clients when I use AI tools on their design project?", https://no-spec.com/community/thread/should-i-tell-clients-when-i-use-ai-tools-on-their-design-project/, accessed 2026-11-15.
  1. Staff: spec work, AI and proof of work ·

    Why it matters more for designers than for most

    Clients usually hire a designer for two things: the work itself and the right to use it exclusively. Generative tools touch the second one directly.

    The US Copyright Office's registration guidance for works containing AI-generated material, published March 16, 2023, says copyright protects only material that is the product of human creativity. When a tool receives only a prompt and produces the image, the Office says the "traditional elements of authorship" are determined by the technology, not the person, and that material is not protected and must be disclaimed in a registration. The guidance also says applicants have a duty to disclose AI-generated content that is more than de minimis.

    The Office's Part 2 report on copyrightability, announced January 29, 2025, confirmed the same line: outputs can be protected only where a human author has determined sufficient expressive elements, which can include creative arrangement or modification of the output, "but not the mere provision of prompts." It also says that using AI to assist the process, or including AI material in a larger human work, does not bar copyright in the human parts.

    So if a logo, illustration or pattern you deliver is mostly generated, your client may not be able to stop someone else from copying it, and may not be able to register it. A client who later finds that out from someone else is likely to feel misled.

    What counts as use worth disclosing

    Not every tool needs a footnote. A practical split:

    Use Disclose?
    Generated imagery, marks, patterns or type that appear in the final deliverables Yes, always
    Generated material used as a base that you then substantially redrew or modified Yes, and describe your own contribution
    Generated mood boards, references or rough explorations that do not appear in the final work Usually worth mentioning in your process description
    Ordinary editing features such as cleanup, selection or resizing inside your design software Generally not, unless your client asks

    The Copyright Office guidance itself notes that editing tools have long been part of the process. What matters is "the extent to which the human had creative control over the work's expression." Your disclosure should help the client see where that line falls in their project.

    How to disclose

    1. Ask first. Some clients, especially in regulated or brand sensitive sectors, forbid generated material entirely. Find out in the brief.
    2. Put it in the agreement. Say whether generative tools may be used, for which stages, and whether generated material can appear in final deliverables. Add a warranty that covers only what you control: that the human authored parts are your original work, and that you have disclosed any generated parts.
    3. Keep a record. Note which assets involved a generator, what you did to them, and when. This is also your proof of authorship if ownership is ever questioned.
    4. Say it plainly at handover. A sentence in the delivery email listing any generated elements is enough.

    If you have ever wondered why disclosure makes a pitch stronger rather than weaker, the thread on refusing free logo concepts makes the same point about process: clients trust what they can see. And if a client cancels after learning about generated material late in a project, the kill fee clause in this thread is what protects your time.

    Copyright rules on generated material differ outside the US and are still developing. This answer summarizes the US Copyright Office's published position as of the dates above. For contract wording you can adapt, try the AI disclosure clause builder on no-spec.com, and have a lawyer review it if a large project depends on ownership.

    1
    ReplyLink

Plain text or simple Markdown. Links are nofollow. Your email is never shown.

no-spec Community. Questions and answers on the business side of freelance design: rates, contracts, briefs, getting paid, spec work, and AI and proof of work.