HubSW

Spec Work: Unpaid Pitches, Contests and How to Say No

The short answer. Spec work is design produced before anyone has agreed to pay for it: the free pitch, the logo contest, the "show us a few ideas first" request and, more and more, the generated mockup a client wants in place of a paid concept round. This lane explains what counts as spec, what it costs you, and how to decline without losing the client.

It is written for working designers, freelance and in-house, and for the clients and procurement teams who write the briefs. AIGA, the US professional association for design, sets out the core position in plain words: designers should be compensated fairly and should negotiate ownership and use rights through an agreement with clients, and should understand the risks before they take on speculative work. Every page in this lane builds on that line.

What counts as spec work, and what does not?

Not all unpaid work is spec. A pro bono job you chose, a self-initiated portfolio piece and a paid test project are different things. Spec is unpaid work made in the hope of being paid, usually in competition with other designers, for a client who keeps the option to walk away with the ideas. Our definition of spec work draws those lines with examples, and the guide to design contests covers the crowdsourced version, where dozens of people work and one gets paid.

The Graphic Artists Guild leaves the choice to each designer but names the price. Article 29 of its Code of Fair Practice says that people who accept speculative assignments or enter contests risk losing anticipated fees, expenses and the chance to pursue other, rewarding assignments.

What does a free pitch actually cost you?

More than the hours. A two-day pitch is two days you did not bill, plus the "small tweaks to help us decide", plus ideas you can no longer sell to anyone else. Multiply that by every designer in the round and the client has collected weeks of professional time for nothing. The spec work cost calculator runs the arithmetic in your browser from your hours, your rate and the number of entrants, and gives you a sentence to paste into your reply.

If you need the argument in one place for a client, ten reasons to refuse spec work makes the case from both sides of the table: thinner briefs, rushed thinking and a result with no process behind it.

How has the free pitch changed with generative tools?

The request now often reads "just mock up a few options, it only takes a minute with AI." A fast image generator does not change who reads the brief, who judges the options or who refines the winner, and it does not change who carries the unpaid risk. Spec work in the AI era explains why the old argument still holds, and AI mockups as the new unpaid pitch gives you wording for the reply.

Big brands fall into the pattern too, and they can be talked out of it. The Guild's advocacy timeline records that in February 2022, after Guild guidance, Adobe issued a statement renouncing work on speculation and said it would revise its Creative Challenges.

Which page answers your question?

Spec work situations and where to start
Your situationStart here
A prospect wants three logo concepts before signingWhat is spec work?
You have been invited to enter a design contestDesign contests, explained
You want a figure for what a pitch gives awaySpec value calculator
A client asks for quick generated mockups firstGenerated mockups and the unpaid pitch
You need arguments a client will acceptThe ten reasons
You want the history and the associations' positionsThe record

Saying no works best when a paid route is ready to offer instead: a priced discovery phase, a paid concept round or a short contract. The rates and contracts lane covers that half of the conversation, and the profession's record on spec shows you are not the first designer to hold the line.

Maintained by the no-spec editors. Last reviewed November 10, 2026.

SW

Start with these pages

  1. SW 01Start 1What Is Spec Work? Definition, Examples and What to SaySpec work is unpaid design done before anyone agrees to pay. See the forms it takes, why AIGA and RGD advise against it, and a reply you can send instead.
  2. SW 02Start 2Ten Reasons Designers Refuse Spec Work (and Clients Lose)Ten reasons designers refuse spec work: unpaid labour, weaker design, murky ownership. Plus why speculation hurts clients too, and a reply to send instead.
  3. SW 03Start 3Design Contests: The Real Math, the IP Risks, Fair OptionsA design contest pays one winner and asks everyone else to work free. See the expected value per entrant, the rights risks, and when a contest can be fair.
  4. SW 04Start 4Spec Work in the AI Era: The Free Pitch, Now AI-GeneratedSpec work did not end when image generators arrived. The free pitch is now AI-generated, faster to ask for and harder to refuse. Four forms, a table, a reply.
  5. AP 06Start 5AI Mockups Are the New Unpaid PitchAn AI mockup is a finished-looking render with the price anchored at zero. What an AI-generated mockup lacks, how to price the real work, and what to reply.
  6. TL 02Start 6Spec Work Cost Calculator: What a Free Pitch Costs YouSpec work cost calculator: what an unpaid pitch or design contest entry costs you at your rate, what it costs the field, and a reply to send the client.
RC

How the pages fit together

The pages in Spec Work: Unpaid Pitches, Contests and How to Say No6 swatch chips, one per page, in the order to read them: SW 01 What Is Spec Work? Definition, Examples and What to Say; SW 02 Ten Reasons Designers Refuse Spec Work (and Clients Lose); SW 03 Design Contests: The Real Math, the IP Risks, Fair Options; SW 04 Spec Work in the AI Era: The Free Pitch, Now AI-Generated; AP 06 AI Mockups Are the New Unpaid Pitch; TL 02 Spec Work Cost Calculator: What a Free Pitch Costs You.SW 01What Is Spec Work? Definition, Examples and...SW 02Ten Reasons Designers Refuse Spec Work (and...SW 03Design Contests: The Real Math, the IP...SW 04Spec Work in the AI Era: The Free Pitch, Now...AP 06AI Mockups Are the New Unpaid PitchTL 02Spec Work Cost Calculator: What a Free Pitch...
Figure 1. The pages in Spec Work: Unpaid Pitches, Contests and How to Say No in the order most readers need them. The chip code places each page in its hub: SW for this one, TL for a tool.
NS

More from no-spec