Skip to content
no-spec Community

Is an unpaid test project from an agency spec work?

Staff answerWritten by no-spec proof desk · Spec work and free pitches0 replies

Short answer

Often, yes. If the test uses the agency's real client or brief, could be used in their work, or takes more than a short exercise, it is unpaid production work and fits the usual definition of spec. A short, generic skills test with no commercial use is closer to an interview. Ask which one it is before you start.

Written by no-spec proof desk · Staff: spec work, AI and proof of work ·
Citeno-spec Community, "Is an unpaid test project from an agency spec work?", https://no-spec.com/community/thread/is-an-unpaid-test-project-from-an-agency-spec-work/, accessed 2026-11-21.
  1. Staff: spec work, AI and proof of work ·

    How to tell the difference

    AIGA's Raleigh chapter, in its local perspective on spec work (September 2018), quotes AIGA National's list of kinds of unpaid work: spec work ("work done for free, in hopes of getting paid for it"), competitions, volunteer work, internships and pro bono work. It notes that not all of these are spec, that students and professionals draw the lines in different places, and that in each case the designer and client make the decision and accept the risks.

    A test project sits between "spec" and "interview." These questions usually settle which side it is on.

    Question Closer to an interview Closer to spec work
    Whose brief is it? A made up or past brief A live client or a current pitch
    Could the agency use the result? No, it has no commercial use Yes, it could go into a presentation or a deliverable
    How long will it take? A few hours at most, with a stated time cap Days, or no limit given
    Who owns it? You do, in writing Not stated, or the agency
    Is anyone else doing the same test? Every candidate, as part of a fixed process Many freelancers, with one winner

    If most of your answers land in the right column, you are being asked for free work.

    What the Guild code says about exploratory work

    The Graphic Artists Guild's Code of Fair Practice has two articles that apply directly. Article 16 says that if exploratory work or comprehensives from an assignment are later chosen for reproduction, the artist's permission should be secured and the artist should receive fair additional payment. Article 17 says that if exploratory work is bought with the intention that another artist will do the finished work, this should be in writing when the order is placed. A test project whose ideas are later developed by someone else is exactly the situation these articles describe, except that nobody paid for the exploratory work at all.

    These are a professional body's published standards, not law, and this forum is not affiliated with the Guild or AIGA.

    What to ask the agency

    Before you agree, send a short message:

    Thanks for the opportunity. Before I start, could you confirm whose brief the test is based on, how long you expect it to take, whether it might be used in client work, and that I keep ownership of what I submit? If it's based on a live project, I'd be glad to do it as a short paid trial at my day rate.

    A reasonable agency will answer. One that will not say whether the work goes to a client has told you what you need to know.

    Alternatives you can offer

    1. A paid trial. A capped number of hours at your rate, on a real task, with a written agreement. This is common and fair.
    2. A walkthrough of a past project. Show your files and explain the decisions. It shows more about how you think than a cold test does.
    3. A short live exercise. A timed sketching or critique session in an interview, with nothing taken away.

    The reply patterns in the free concepts thread work here too. And if the "test" is really a contest among several freelancers, the trade offs in the design contest thread apply.

    Putting a value on it

    It helps to know what you would be giving away. The spec work cost calculator on no-spec.com turns the hours a test would take into the fee you would normally charge for them, which makes the conversation about a paid trial much easier.

    0
    ReplyLink

Plain text or simple Markdown. Links are nofollow. Your email is never shown.

no-spec Community. Questions and answers on the business side of freelance design: rates, contracts, briefs, getting paid, spec work, and AI and proof of work.